The only ones out-breeding the Muslims


April 27, 2013 by Alex Johannigman

A few nights ago I went out to dinner and drinks with a good friend and mentor to talk about a study series for my young adult group at church that I’ll be leading starting next week. We briefly talked about how his fourth child is due in less than 2 months, and how he wants to design a bumper sticker for his car (he’ll probably need a mini-van soon) that says “Catholics: We’re the only ones out-breeding the Muslims.”

Many would be quick to connect this to the fact that Catholics believe that artificial birth control is morally not so good (to put it lightly), but considering that a) statistics tell us both that most Catholics don’t understand the teaching anyway, and b) NFP methods are just as effective as artificial birth control at avoiding pregnancy, there’s got to be more to it than just that.

(As an aside, can I just mention how happy this new tumblr account makes me?)

So why would it be that I have Catholic friends who have told me, on the mild side, that they want “at least 5,” kids, and in some cases have said things (mostly joking) like “I want to have 9 kids, and adopt 9 more,” or “I just want to keep cranking them out.” And I’ve had a handful of co-workers give me funny looks when I tell them that I want at least 4 or 5 kids myself, which is usually followed by them wishing me luck finding a wife who wants more than 2 or maybe 3 kids who isn’t also totally crazy. A couple weeks ago I went to an event to hear a married couple with 7 kids talk about their faith and marriage, and rather than talk about how sorry they felt for the couple, most of the young professionals in attendance thought it was really cool that they had such a big family and hoped that they’d have one like theirs someday too. The speakers also mentioned that parenting was the most difficult with 2 and 3 kids, but then got easier when they had 4 or more, which means a lot of families are making it hard on themselves when they stop at the ideal 1 boy, 1 girl, and the white picket fence in the suburbs.

One thing that I really like about Catholicism is that it treats children, and all people for that matter, as a gift and not as a commodity. And it was only recently that I began to realize that this was very different from the typical American mindset. (Marc Barnes helped) I’ve talked to a couple med student friends in the past week who have mentioned their irritation with the popular mindset in med school that thinks of patients as “costs to the healthcare system” and not as living, valuable people. And it’s hard to not notice our shrinking birth rate as a country which is driven by a general desire for a smaller family.

I’m realizing as I type this that this mindset of people as commodities and not as gifts is a result of a troubling lack of love for others and an insistence on achieving whatever we selfishly think will make us as individuals happiest. We’re now making so many of our decisions based on what will make ME happiest, wealthiest, and healthiest. And as a result we see things like high abortion rates, high divorce rates, small families, and a looming economic crisis as the number of workers supporting each retired person shrinks lower and lower, and is now less than 3 and will only get smaller as more baby boomers hit retirement age.

I brought social security into this, and now this post is about love, religion, and politics. Clever, I know.

I brought social security into this, and now this post is about love, religion, and politics. Clever, I know.

But that’s a topic for another post when I feel like ranting about how unsustainable our government is right now.

The ironic thing is that focusing on what YOU want and what makes YOU happiest tends to not actually make you happy in the long term. My friends who are raising big families are actually among the happiest people I know, and my friends who are from large families wouldn’t trade it for anything. I’m not trying to suggest that all people who want small families are bad or selfish, but I am saying that there are a good number of people who are trying to limit the size of their family because they think it will make them happier because they’ll have more money, or more time to go on the trip they always wanted to go on, or have a better chance of getting that next promotion at work, rather than out of genuine concern for being able to provide for an extra child. And that can be sinful even for couples using NFP if they are using it with what we like to call the “contraceptive mindset,” and not being open to life for all the wrong reasons.

So, in summary: Babies are awesome. The world needs more of them, or else we’re about to be in serious trouble. And we need to treasure all humans as the awesome people that they are.


4 thoughts on “The only ones out-breeding the Muslims

  1. Ed says:

    Nice entry, Alex. Count me among one of those who wants “at least five.” 😉


  2. lj41 says:

    “Someone who sees the world as only black or white is more than merely colorblind.” – Kurt Poleet


  3. Anon says:

    I would like to have one or two biological kids, but then I would like to adopt, first babies and then maybe older kids (they have such a hard time finding a family). I don’t know why…


    • Sounds like a great plan. At least in the Dallas area (not sure about elsewhere) the demand for adopting babies actually exceeds the supply now (there are a ton of adults wanting to adopt babies, but not very many babies up for adoption, unfortunately probably because abortion is viewed as an easier option), but that’s awesome that you’re willing to adopt older kids since they do have such a hard time finding loving families.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to keep up with all of the awesome things at All That Catholic Jazz and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 267 other followers

Buy a Blogger a Beer

Blogging takes a lot of time and it costs me money to keep this site active. Please consider helping to offset the costs of running this blog, or contribute money to my craft beer fund so I can have inspiration for future posts.


My Bookshelf

%d bloggers like this: